Should You Do a Roth Conversion in Retirement? 5 Critical Factors That Most People Miss

Roth conversions aren't automatically smart moves. Without proper analysis of tax brackets, cash availability, hidden costs, state taxes, and investment strategy, conversions can actually leave you with less money in retirement, not more.

The Roth Conversion Trap That Costs Retirees Hundreds of Thousands

Most people think Roth conversions are always a smart move. You pay the taxes now and everything grows tax-free later, right? Here's the problem: if you convert at the wrong time or without a comprehensive strategy, it can actually leave you with less money in retirement, not more. The biggest mistake I see is assuming Roth conversions are either universally good or bad without running the actual numbers for your specific situation. But there are five key factors that get consistently overlooked, and they can completely change whether this strategy helps or devastates your retirement plan.

In this article, I'll walk you through these five critical considerations using real examples and detailed analysis. By the end, you'll know whether Roth conversions make sense for you and how to avoid the costly mistakes most people make.

The Cash Availability Problem

Here's what most people don't realize about Roth conversions: you need cash outside your retirement accounts to make them work effectively.

When you do a Roth conversion, you're transferring money from a pre-tax retirement account into an after-tax Roth IRA. This creates a taxable event, so you'll owe income taxes on the converted amount.

Let's say you do a $100,000 Roth conversion with a $30,000 tax bill. If you don't have outside money to pay those taxes, only $70,000 actually goes into your Roth account. The other $30,000 goes to the government, severely limiting your long-term tax-free growth potential.

Client Example: The $1.2 Million Difference

Meet John and Sara. Both retired at ages 64 and 63. They each have $500,000 in traditional IRAs, totaling $1 million in retirement savings.

When we analyzed converting up to the 22-25% tax bracket without outside cash to pay taxes, they actually ended up with almost $70,000 less in their portfolio because they had to use retirement funds to pay the conversion taxes.

But here's where it gets interesting: when we gave them an additional $500,000 in a taxable brokerage account to pay conversion taxes, they added almost $1 million more in tax-adjusted wealth. Combined with an optimal withdrawal sequence, they maximized their wealth by over $1.2 million throughout retirement.

The lesson? Building assets in taxable brokerage accounts can make the difference between Roth conversions helping or hurting your retirement plan.

The Hidden Tax Landmines

This is where most people get blindsided. Roth conversions increase your Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI), which can trigger several additional costs that aren't obvious in basic conversion calculations.

Medicare IRMAA Premiums: If your MAGI exceeds certain thresholds, you'll pay higher Medicare premiums for two years after the conversion. IRMAA uses a two-year lookback period, so today's conversion affects your premiums years later.

ACA Subsidy Loss: If you're under 65 and buying health insurance through the marketplace, a large conversion could eliminate your premium subsidies for that year. Since ACA subsidies are based on a sliding scale of MAGI, higher income means less (or zero) assistance.

Social Security Taxation: Higher MAGI can push up to 85% of your Social Security benefits into taxable territory, creating a double tax hit.

These hidden taxes don't necessarily mean you shouldn't convert, but you need to factor them into your decision. Sometimes it makes sense to spread conversions across multiple years to stay under these thresholds.

The Geographic Arbitrage Opportunity

If you live in a high-tax state like California (13% state tax) or New York (10.9%) but plan to retire to a no-tax state like Florida, Texas, or Tennessee, the timing of your conversions becomes crucial.

Why pay California's 13% state tax on a conversion when you could wait until you're a Florida resident and pay zero state tax? This single decision can save tens of thousands of dollars.

There are 13 states that either have no income tax or don't tax retirement account distributions. If you're planning a move, consider delaying conversions until you become a resident of your new state.

The Charity Consideration

If you're planning to leave a significant portion of your wealth to charity, Roth conversions might actually reduce your charitable impact.

Here's why: Charities don't pay income taxes. When they inherit your traditional IRA, they receive the full amount tax-free. But if you convert to Roth, you pay taxes upfront, leaving less total money for the charity.

Example:

Leave $100,000 in traditional IRA to charity: They get $100,000
Convert to Roth (paying $24,000 in taxes), then leave $76,000 to charity: They get $76,000

The smarter strategy:

Once you turn 70½, make Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs) directly from your traditional IRA to charity, up to $100,000 per year. This counts toward required minimum distributions, reduces your taxable income, and maximizes your charitable impact.

The Investment Strategy Reality Check

Here's a factor most people never consider: Roth conversions only work if the converted money actually grows. If you convert $100,000 and invest it conservatively in bonds earning 3%, you might not generate enough tax-free growth to justify paying the conversion taxes upfront.

But if that same $100,000 grows at 8% in a diversified stock portfolio, the tax-free compounding becomes incredibly powerful. I often tell clients to think of their Roth as their "growth bucket." If you're going to do conversions, invest that money for long-term growth. If you're too conservative with the investments, the conversion math probably doesn't work.

Putting It All Together: Your Roth Conversion Decision Framework

Here are the key factors that determine whether a Roth conversion helps or hurts you:

Cash Availability: Do you have money outside your IRA to pay taxes? Without it, you're stunting growth by using retirement funds for taxes.
Tax Bracket Strategy: What's the optimal bracket for conversions? Don't assume it's always the highest or lowest, it's different for everyone.
Hidden Tax Awareness: Factor in potential impacts on Medicare premiums, ACA subsidies, and Social Security taxation.
State Tax Planning: Are you moving to a lower-tax state? If so, timing your move before conversions could save thousands.
Charitable Intent: If you're leaving money to charity, QCDs might be better than conversions.
Investment Approach: Treat your Roth as your growth bucket to maximize the conversion benefit.

If most factors point toward conversions:

Start modeling specific amounts and timelines
Consider working with a financial planner who specializes in tax planning
Don't convert everything at once. Spread it over multiple years

If factors are mixed or mostly negative:

Consider partial conversions or wait for better timing
Focus on other tax planning strategies
Revisit the analysis when your situation changes

The key is running the numbers for your specific situation rather than making assumptions based on general advice.

Need help planning your retirement? Book a no-obligation intro call so we can show you how we've helped hundreds of people live their best life in retirement.